|
Note: Porter five forces is an industry analysis technique
that can be used to quickly
understand the expected nature of competition in
your industry, for an overview of this technique click here
"What will happen to your profits if the nature of competition in
your
industry changes?"
Discover how to analyze your industry environment and
determine how aggressive your competitors will
be Written by Ian
Pratt
Great! You are using the porter five
forces model to complete your industry analysis. Now let's look
at the "Rivalry
amongst existing firms" in your industry.
The rivalry amongst existing firms
analysis will help you to understand the risk that
your competitors may compete for
market position and if their competitive tactics are likely to
be effective.
You will find that
your competitors may compete for market position using
tactics such as;
Read on
to discover how likely it
is that your competitors will use these tactics and successfully lure your customers away.
Industry Rivalry Example (using the porter five forces model)
You maybe concerned about the
aggressive price position of one of your competitors;
however, you are aware that
demand for your product outstrips supply and that due to significant barriers to
entry other businesses are not likely to enter into your market.
Given these circumstances, you are unlikely to be forced to respond
to your competitors low prices with lower prices of your own.
Let's explore Industry Rivalry in more detail
Please review each of the factors that
affect industry rivalry in more detail and use our free
template to
assess the risk of rivalry in your industry.
The following factors will help
you
to analyze your industry rivalry, click on each for more details and
ignore those not relevant to your industry.
What makes a good leader
has
provided strategic planning templates for each of the forces in the porter five forces model. The industry rivalry template is at the bottom of this page, take me
there
Industry Growth Rate
If your products are in the early
stages of the product life
cycle, i.e. your industry is in a growth phase,
then their will be room for all businesses in your industry to grow.
This will result in a low risk of competitor rivalry.
As your
industry matures, demand flattens or even goes into decline, the only way for one business to grow
is at the expense on another, (win / loose). In mature and declining
markets, there will be a lot of rivalry in the industry.
Return to Index
High Fixed Cost
If the fixed cost is a high
proportion of the total costs
for the industry then each competitor will
seek to maintain volume, which will drive higher competitor rivalry.
Alternatively, if fixed costs are only
a small portion of total costs then
the industry is likely to reduce supply
when demand drops, reducing the risk of competitive rivalry.
Return to Index
Intermittent Over Capacity
Intermittent over capacity exists in
industries that have the same capacity all year and supply to
a seasonal demand, or in industries where supply can only be
increased in large lumps, such as adding an extra shift to
a car manufacturing plant.
During the periods
of over capacity in the industry (too much supply) there
is likely to be increased competitor rivalry.
Return to Index
Product Differences
Are your and your
competitors products/services similar or are you easily able
to differentiate your products and services?
If your
customers perceive that your products or services are
different to your competitors and your customer values that
difference, then you have some protection from competitor rivalry.
If your customer perceives
that your products/services are essentially the same as others
in your industry then competitor rivalry is more likely.
Return to Index
Brand Identity
Are there any strong
brands in your industry? Do consumers have a brand preference?
In industries where the consumer has
a strong brand preference there is a lower risk of competitive rivalry.
Return to Index
Switching Costs
What are the costs for your customer
to switch to one of your competitors products?
Switching cost is the amount your customer would have to
spend to switch to your competitors products.
The lower the switching costs the
easier it will be for your competitors
to attract your customers, increasing the risk of competitor rivalry.
Return to Index
Informational Complexity
What is the
information complexity of products in your industry?
If products in your industry are hard to understand, say your
product is business insurance, customers are less likely
to invest time to try to understand the differences between products
in the industry, reducing the risk of competitor rivalry.
Return to Index
Concentration and balance
If your industry only has a few
competitors who are all happy with their market share then the
risk of competitor rivalry is low. Alternatively, if there are
a lot of competitors or any one competitor is not happy with
their position in the market then there is a high risk
of competitor rivalry.
Return to Index
Industry Commitment
If your industry consists of
businesses that only cater for your industry then they are
likely to be more committed to your industry and remain in the
industry even if results are poor, increasing the risk of
competitor rivalry.
However,
if your industry includes divisions
of major global conglomerates then they maybe less willing
to incur consecutive years of losses, which reduces
the risk of
competitor rivalry.
Return to Index
Exit Barriers
If there are high barriers preventing a firm from exiting an industry it is
likely that they will be prepared to operate at a marginal profit
or loss and your should expect high competitor rivalry.
An example, the firm has a
large capital investment in plant and equipment and other
buyers are unlikely to be interested in the equipment, Return to
Index
Porter Five Forces Exercise
Before you can
complete an analysis of your industry rivalry you will
need to identify which factors, above, are relevant to your
industry.
(Indicate below which of the following
factors are relevant for your industry).
Return to
Index
Strategic
Planning Template for your Industry Rivalry
what makes a good leader has provided free
strategic planning templates throughout our site, the porter
five forces model includes five templates. The industry rivalry
template is provided for your use, below.
|
Industry
Rivalry |
Comment on Industry
Rivalry
|
Rating
|
|
Industry Growth
Rate
|
|
|
|
High Fixed Cost
|
|
|
|
Intermittent Over
Capacity
|
|
|
|
Product
Differences
|
|
|
|
Brand
Identity
|
|
|
|
Switching
Costs
|
|
|
|
Informational
Complexity
|
|
|
| Concentration and
balance |
|
|
| Diversity of
Competitors |
|
|
| Corporate
Stakes |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Industry Rivalry overall rating
|
|
Porter Five Forces model templates,
by whatmakesagoodleader.com
Where to from here?
Why not complete your industry analysis
by reviewing all five forces
in the Porter Five Forces
model?
And update your SWOT analysis with all opportunities and
threats that you identified while using the Porter Five Forces
Model.
Return to Index
Return to Top
|